A man of many firsts
Guest post by Dechen Pemba
Dr Tsewang Yishey Pemba, who has died aged 79, was the first Tibetan to be trained in western medicine, and served as consultant physician to Bhutan’s royal family.
Dr Tsewang Yishey Pemba, MBBS (London) FRCS He can claim many firsts. With an MBBS degree from University college hospital, London in 1955, Dr Pemba was the first Tibetan student to receive a British medical qualification.
He helped to found the first hospital in Paro, Bhutan, and in 1967 became the first Tibetan to obtain the fellowship of the Royal College of Surgeons.
Extra to his medical achievements, Dr Pemba is widely regarded to have written the first work of fiction by a Tibetan in English, “Idols on the Path”, published in 1966.
Dr Pemba was born in 1932 in Gyantse, Tibet. His father’s work with the British mission in Tibet meant that he spent his childhood in Gyantse, Yatung, and also Lhasa, where he was present at the installation of the 14th Dalai Lama. Although receiving no formal education until the age of 9, Dr Pemba thrived at Victoria School in Kurseong, West Bengal, India and in 1949 went on to study for his medical degree at University College, London, UK.
Following a short stint working at a hospital in Kalimpong, West Bengal, Dr Pemba was recruited in 1956 by the future Prime Minister of Bhutan, Jigme Dorji, to work as a medical officer in the town of Paro.
At the time, there were only three modern trained doctors in the country and, with no electricity, water, modern roads or communications, he had to walk everywhere or ride horses and mules. It was during this period that he wrote his memoirs “Young Days in Tibet”, published by Jonathan Cape in 1957, the first autobiographical account by a Tibetan in English.
By 1959, Dr Pemba was back in Darjeeling, working in Dooars & Darjeeling medical association hospital (DDMA), a hospital under the aegis of the Indian Tea association. With the uprising in Lhasa, Tibet, against the occupying Chinese forces, thousands of refugees were fleeing to India, many crowding into Darjeeling.
Dr Pemba spent his free time in this period working as a volunteer for the Tibetan refugee school and the Tibetan refugee self-help centre. Dr Pemba could count every prominent Tibetan refugee, monk and official, who fled from Tibet as one of his patients.
His 1966 novel, “Idols on the Path” was born in this period and based on the fledgling Tibetan diaspora. For his medical work, Dr Pemba became a well-known and prominent figure in the Himalayas.
In 1965, Dr Pemba returned to London to train as a surgeon. He was awarded the Hallett Prize in 1966 for standing first in the primary examinations of the royal college of surgeons and in 1967 obtained their fellowship.
On returning to India, Dr Pemba worked in Darjeeling, he befriended famous Catholic thinker Thomas Merton in this period, and moved back to Bhutan in the mid-1980s to become Superintendent of the National Referral Hospital, Thimphu. Until 1992, Dr Pemba lived in Bhutan and was an appointed United Nations certifying doctor, sat on the committee devising a Bhutan national formulary and, in 1989, was a member of the Bhutan delegation to WHO in Geneva.
Dr Pemba served as consulting physician to Bhutan’s royal family in this period as well.
Dr Pemba officially retired in 1992, but worked privately and also travelled extensively to the USA, Europe and Japan. Between 2000 and 2005, he made several visits to New York and worked, for a period, as a lecturer in anatomy and physiology. In 2007, Dr Pemba paid a visit to Tibet after almost 60 years, “capturing old memories and renewing ties and seeing a totally changed Tibet”.
Beyond the medical profession, Dr Pemba was an avid follower of the arts, and never stopped reading and writing fiction, even up to his last days. Dr Pemba is survived by his wife, Tsering Sangmo, and four children, a fifth child pre-deceased him in 2009.
Dr Tsewang Yishey Pemba, born June 5 1932, died November 26 2011.
Wow! So, it appears there have been smart Tibetans unlike the majority of Tibetans today (especially in the US) who go to community colleges or no-name schools, aim to be just nurses or some technicians (or have high goals like engineering only to restudy to become a CNA). It is not to deny the few among us who have attended prestigious colleges and universities and seek advanced degrees etc but it is just a comment on how we Tibetans, especially as a whole, have so few among us (compared to other groups), that 3-4-5 is just not enough.
There is no better way of “fighting” for Tibet than by representing the group by achieving greater accolades, attending prestigious universities and working or interacting with the best in this country.
The true value of ones contribution to the community as a whole should not be measured by the degree or professional position you hold but by the actual contributions of your actions.
It is no easy feat to become a nurse, technician, or CNA. It takes hard work and dedication. Some of these individuals are supporting other individuals education in “prestigious” colleges. Lets not discourage those who are working hard. Tibetan nurses have contributed to the welfare of their community for years in India, choosing to accept a lower salary in Tibetan clinics than better pay in cities. Those in the west have been able to provide assistance and help Tibetans who cannot access the health care system economically or linguistically.
Lets not engage in dis-empowering members of our community who are nurses, doctors, engineers, or grocery clerks. We should be encouraging our young to strive to prestigious positions or degree but more importantly we should be clear that their actions, not their degree, will ultimately make the difference to our community.
According to this short article, that Dr Tsewang Yishy Pemba was surely a man of many firsts. The first Tibetan to be trained in western medicine. The first Tibetan student to receive a British medical qualification. The first Tibetan to obtain the fellowship of the Royal College of Surgeons. The first to have written the first work of fiction by a Tibetan in English, so on.
Wow, so many firsts, amazing! I think that’s because of Tibet or the loss of Tibet , Tibetan people, Tibetan culture and the Dalai Lama that gave him the opportunity to be the man he was.
We all could imagine that then Tibetan government in exile clearly needed someone like him to open the eyes of Tibetans to step into a world of Health Care Education. To be the leader to produce tibetan doctors and nurses to follow the foot steps of other countries.
He was now fully trained in Western Medicine. But his enthusiam and patriotism was brutally disappeared from his heart. Tibetan people and Tibet were in a serious storm that was gradually blowing endangered tibetan language, religion and culture away from the world. But he never hesitated to divert his direction to Bhutan to serve Bhutanese and their Royal Family instead of assisting his spiritual leader and sympathetically working with his same-blooded brothers and sisters.
For me, that he does not deserve a tiny place in our recent history. He died with a Tibetan name and zero acheivement in our needy Tibetan societies throughout the world. Since 1949, many tibetans gave up their lives for our freedom and rights. But he simply couldn’t sacrifice a small amount of his time in our exiled societies. He has neither left rewardable reputation nor influential work for us to remember him.
He might have had some untold stories to tell us why he wasn’t there for us when we needed him. And a desperate cry in his heart that a particular circumstance stopped him contributing his energy and knowledge in our societies.
“Dr Pemba spent his free time in this period working as a volunteer for the Tibetan refugee school and the Tibetan refugee self-help centre. Dr Pemba could count every prominent Tibetan refugee, monk and official, who fled from Tibet as one of his patients.”
He also wrote a memoir: ‘“Young Days in Tibet”, published by Jonathan Cape in 1957, the first autobiographical account by a Tibetan in English.’
Anyway, it seems pretty heartless to criticize someone’s eulogy. His niece and Lhakar Diaries decided to honor this amazing man. It doesn’t take away from what you may or may not do yourself.
You wrote…
For me, that he does not deserve a tiny place in our recent history. He died with a Tibetan name and zero acheivement in our needy Tibetan societies throughout the world. Since 1949, many tibetans gave up their lives for our freedom and rights. But he simply couldn’t sacrifice a small amount of his time in our exiled societies. He has neither left rewardable reputation nor influential work for us to remember him.
And you sign yourself “Anonymous”. What or who are you hiding from?
Readers are entitled to wonder what achievements you have made in your career so far. And in what fields?
I remember Dr Pemba la. He was a very kind man and for many years offered his services free to us in the CST Darjeeling school. I also know for fact that he was very kind to indigent Tibetans who came to his hospital; they were never charged a dime and on many occasions provided free medicines also. Even when he was working in Bhutan, Tibetans there benefited from his services. He was a patriotic Tibetan and a great role model. I am saddened by his demise. I never had a chance to thank him for the medical care he has given us and want to say Thank you Dr. Pemba la here. I offer my condolences to his family. To that “Anonymous” writer, I would say ask yourself what have you done before trying to discount Dr Pemba la. There was a long article in Tibetan News Paper printed in Darleeling praising Dr Pemba la for his service but I forgot the date and name of the paper now. Perhaps, the paper was called “Rawang Ranzen” or “Sheja”. I know it is no longer printed now.
An Email sent by me to Old Boys a of Victoria and Dow Hill School in Kurseong.
G’day folks,
Sad news indeed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/8981393/Tsewang-Yishey-Pemba.html
and
https://lhakardiaries.com/2011/12/14/a-man-of-many-firsts/
As mentioned in the Obit he was an old boy, like me of Victoria School, Kurseong, West Bengal. Although before my time. his brother followed him to VS and was there at the same time as I was.
From…
The Headmaster’s Diaries – December 1946.
Htaw, Namey, and Malla passed in the first grade and seven boys were placed in the second grade. The Juniors results were also good. T.Y. Pemba passed third in Bengal with 7 ‘A’s, and 2 ‘C’s out of nine subjects. {This would have been the Junior Cambridge Exams].
24/10/1948
Final Debate of the year judged by Fr Prior, Miss Christian of Dow Hill, and our Mr Bloud. Y. Pemba, the Secretary of the Debating Society, was adjudged the best in the Senior branch and G. White, in the Juniors
In 1948 He got a 1st in the Senior Cambridge Exams.
1950. – From the Old Victorians Association News – Congratulations to Yishey Pemba on passing his First M.B. (London).
Vale. Yishi Pemba.
Note; He made the Obits in The London Daily Telegraph.
John Feltham
Townsville,
North Queensland
Australia
It seems his progessional career could not contribute to his own refugee community but that of tiny Bhutanese king….lol…Money talks! Tibetan Refugee community is rotten with TB’s due to lack of medical advisors and doctors….Hope future Tibs will keep one’s own house in order before maintaining house order in “other’s” home….
Pingback: “Falling Through the Roof” by Thubten Samphel
Anonymous wrote “Wow, so many firsts, amazing! I think that’s because of Tibet or the loss of Tibet , Tibetan people, Tibetan culture and the Dalai Lama that gave him the opportunity to be the man he was.”
This is someone’s eulogy, you must be a very misserable person to try and take down the merits of another. The FRCS exam is a test that all the surgeons in England had to take, so how does coming in number 1 from all the doctors of england on a knowlege based test have to do with “Tibet”. Dr. Pemba was honored by both the Telegraph and the Times of UK (The times published a full page color in their newspaper). You are Tibetan, and you should be proud that another country man, has achieved so much success and not try and belittle him,
Pingback: High Peaks Pure Earth – “The Tibetan Suitcase: A Novel” By Tsering Namgyal Khortsa
I, Chatru Jhangiani, had met him several times from mid 70s and had made been very close to his family. I often remember him for his typical Breitish Humor and a great host that he was. Recently I have tried to reach his family but has not been sucessful specially his daughter Lahmo and his son who I last know was settled in USA.If any one reading this and could help me in contacting his family would be obliged. I live in Kolkata and you can reach me over phone no. +919830547349..
I’m very happy to uncover this site. I want to to thank you for ones time for this wonderful read!!
I definitely liked every bit of it and i also have you bookmarked to check out new stuff on your site.
Great article Dechen la. I remember Dr Pemba from my school days in Mount Hermon and the last time I met him with his late son Karma Pema who was a friend. He saved many people’s lives both rich and poor. May his soul rest in peace.
Of course, he may claim for many many firsts, but as he is a truly learned man he never did it like today’s our poor guys who are mad for only names.
Pingback: "The Tibetan Suitcase: A Novel" By Tsering Namgyal Khortsa – HighPeakPureEarth